OnlyFans and similar platforms are often presented through competing narratives. One tells a story of liberation: creators exercising agency, controlling their images, schedules, and earnings, bypassing gatekeepers in traditional media. Another narrative emphasizes precarious labor and exposure: the pressure to constantly produce, the emotional toll of performative availability, and the risk of dehumanizing feedback from anonymous consumers. Both narratives are true in part, and both shape how we interpret a creator’s work and the responses it attracts.